Difference between revisions of "Weapon Analysis"

From UFOpaedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (→‎Quantitative Analysis: link to kill modelling description)
(→‎Apocalypse: redlink for later)
 
(39 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
__NOTOC__
 
__NOTOC__
This section is intended as a place to collate articles or discussions where the merits of the various weapons are gauged or compared.
 
  
The scope of the articles can span between UFO and TFTD and can cover any weapons in either game. This includes craft/UFO weapons, hand held weapons or tank turrets/terror unit weapons.  
+
This section is a collection hub for various articles that discuss the merits of the many weapons in the X-COM series. Weapons can range anywhere from hand-held firearms to aircraft weapons.
 +
 
 +
Contents of the respective articles are subject to change. Readers wanting to share alternate views or propose new topics are welcome to join the discussion on the talk pages.
 +
 
 +
=Disclaimer =
 +
 
 +
Though Ufopaedia.org attempts to be factual in its core articles (with some artistic license taken for non-essential descriptions), '''the arguments presented here are strictly the opinion of the respective contributor(s)'''. Readers are encouraged to form their own opinion based on the information presented.  
  
  
 
__TOC__
 
__TOC__
  
----
 
 
=Weapon Debates=
 
=Weapon Debates=
  
 +
==UFO==
 +
:•[[Best Starting Weapons (EU)]]
 +
:•[[Skipping Laser Weapons]]
 +
:•[[Skipping Plasma Weapons]]
 +
:•[[Heavy Cannon vs Auto Cannon]]
 +
:•Rifle Comparisons
 +
::•[[Rifle vs Pistol]]
 +
::•[[Rifle vs Laser Pistol]]
 +
:•[[Laser Pistol vs All Predecessors]]
 +
:•Laser Rifle comparisons
 +
::•[[Laser Rifle vs All Predecessors]]
 +
::•[[Laser Rifle vs Laser Pistol]]
 +
::•[[Laser Rifle vs Heavy Plasma]]
 +
:•Heavy Laser Comparisons
 +
::•[[Heavy Laser vs Heavy Plasma]]
 +
::•[[Heavy Laser vs Heavy Cannon]]
  
[[Best Starting Weapons (EU)]]
+
==TFTD==
  
[[Rifle vs Pistol]]
+
''See also: [[Weapon Effectiveness (TFTD)]]''
  
[[Heavy Cannon vs Auto Cannon]]
+
:•[[Best Starting Weapons (TFTD)]]
 +
:•[[Skipping Gauss Weapons]]
 +
:•[[Skipping Sonic Weapons]]
 +
:•[[Sonic Cannon vs Displacer/Sonic]]
  
[[Rifle vs Laser Pistol]]
+
:•Gas Cannon comparisons 
 +
::•[[Gas Cannon vs Torpedo Launcher]]
 +
::•[[Gas Cannon vs Heavy Gauss ]]  
  
[[Heavy Cannon vs Laser Pistol]]
+
:•Sonic Pistol comparisons
 +
::•[[Sonic Pistol vs Heavy Gauss]]
 +
::•[[Sonic Pistol vs. Gauss Rifle]]
 +
::•[[Sonic Pistol vs. Gauss Pistol]]
 +
::•[[Sonic Pistol vs Sonic Blasta Rifle]]
 +
::•[[Sonic Pistol vs Sonic Cannon]]
  
[[Laser Rifle vs Heavy Plasma]]
+
==Apocalypse==
 +
:•[[Best Starting Weapons (Apocalypse)]]
 +
:•[[Toxigun vs Devastator Cannon]]
  
[[Best Starting Weapons (TFTD)]]
+
==General Discussions==
 +
:•[[Recommended Weapon Research Order]]
 +
:•[[Weapons by Role]]
 +
:•[[Weapons by Role (TFTD)]]
 +
:•[[HE vs single target weapons]]
 +
:•[[Tanks vs Troops]]
  
[[Sonic Pistol vs Heavy Gauss]]
+
==Cross Game Discussions==
 +
:•[[Stun Rod vs Thermal Tazer]]
 +
:•[[High Explosive vs Magna-Pack Explosive]]
 +
:•[[Pistol vs Dart Gun]]
 +
:•[[Rifle vs Jet Harpoon]]
 +
:•[[Heavy Cannon vs Gas Cannon]]
 +
:•[[Auto Cannon vs Hydro-Jet Cannon]]
 +
:•[[Rocket Launcher vs Torpedo Launcher]]
 +
:•[[Laser Pistol vs Gauss Pistol]]
 +
:•[[Laser Rifle vs Gauss Rifle]]
 +
:•[[Heavy Laser vs Heavy Gauss]]
 +
:•[[Plasma Pistol vs Sonic Pistol]]
 +
:•[[Plasma Rifle vs Sonic Blasta Rifle]]
 +
:•[[Heavy Plasma vs Sonic Cannon]]
 +
:•[[Small Launcher vs Thermal Shok Launcher]]
 +
:•[[Blaster Launcher vs Disruptor Pulse Launcher]]
  
[[Sonic Pistol vs Sonic Blasta Rifle]]
+
=Quantitative Analysis=
  
=Quantitative Analysis=
+
Accuracy
 +
 
 +
*[[User_talk:Bomb_Bloke#Firing_Accuracy]]
 +
*[[Firing Accuracy Testing]]
 +
 
 +
Firepower
  
 
*[[Firepower Tables]]
 
*[[Firepower Tables]]
Line 46: Line 103:
 
**[[Talk:Ethereal#Weapon_Rankings_Vs._Ethereals|Ethereal]]
 
**[[Talk:Ethereal#Weapon_Rankings_Vs._Ethereals|Ethereal]]
 
**[[Talk:Sectopod#Weapon_Rankings_Vs._Sectopods|Sectopod]]
 
**[[Talk:Sectopod#Weapon_Rankings_Vs._Sectopods|Sectopod]]
 +
*[[Tank_Firepower|Kill Rankings for Tanks]]
  
 
=Other Discussions=
 
=Other Discussions=
  
[[Accuracy vs TU Efficiency]]
+
*[[Accuracy vs TU Efficiency]]
 
+
*[[Talk:Launcher Weapons]]
= Disclaimer =
+
*[[Aimed, Snap, or Auto?]]
 
 
Though Ufopaedia.org attempts to be factual in its core articles (note that some artistic license may be taken in the non-essential descriptions to add flavour), the cases presented on this page are the opinions of the author(s).
 
  
Care has been taken to provide facts and statistics where ever appropriate to back the arguments, but it is up to the reader to decide how to use make use of this information.
+
[[Category:Weapons]]
 +
[[Category:Weapons (TFTD)]]
 +
[[Category:Enemy Unknown/UFO Defense]]

Latest revision as of 10:57, 26 June 2020


This section is a collection hub for various articles that discuss the merits of the many weapons in the X-COM series. Weapons can range anywhere from hand-held firearms to aircraft weapons.

Contents of the respective articles are subject to change. Readers wanting to share alternate views or propose new topics are welcome to join the discussion on the talk pages.

Disclaimer

Though Ufopaedia.org attempts to be factual in its core articles (with some artistic license taken for non-essential descriptions), the arguments presented here are strictly the opinion of the respective contributor(s). Readers are encouraged to form their own opinion based on the information presented.


Weapon Debates

UFO

Best Starting Weapons (EU)
Skipping Laser Weapons
Skipping Plasma Weapons
Heavy Cannon vs Auto Cannon
•Rifle Comparisons
Rifle vs Pistol
Rifle vs Laser Pistol
Laser Pistol vs All Predecessors
•Laser Rifle comparisons
Laser Rifle vs All Predecessors
Laser Rifle vs Laser Pistol
Laser Rifle vs Heavy Plasma
•Heavy Laser Comparisons
Heavy Laser vs Heavy Plasma
Heavy Laser vs Heavy Cannon

TFTD

See also: Weapon Effectiveness (TFTD)

Best Starting Weapons (TFTD)
Skipping Gauss Weapons
Skipping Sonic Weapons
Sonic Cannon vs Displacer/Sonic
•Gas Cannon comparisons
Gas Cannon vs Torpedo Launcher
Gas Cannon vs Heavy Gauss
•Sonic Pistol comparisons
Sonic Pistol vs Heavy Gauss
Sonic Pistol vs. Gauss Rifle
Sonic Pistol vs. Gauss Pistol
Sonic Pistol vs Sonic Blasta Rifle
Sonic Pistol vs Sonic Cannon

Apocalypse

Best Starting Weapons (Apocalypse)
Toxigun vs Devastator Cannon

General Discussions

Recommended Weapon Research Order
Weapons by Role
Weapons by Role (TFTD)
HE vs single target weapons
Tanks vs Troops

Cross Game Discussions

Stun Rod vs Thermal Tazer
High Explosive vs Magna-Pack Explosive
Pistol vs Dart Gun
Rifle vs Jet Harpoon
Heavy Cannon vs Gas Cannon
Auto Cannon vs Hydro-Jet Cannon
Rocket Launcher vs Torpedo Launcher
Laser Pistol vs Gauss Pistol
Laser Rifle vs Gauss Rifle
Heavy Laser vs Heavy Gauss
Plasma Pistol vs Sonic Pistol
Plasma Rifle vs Sonic Blasta Rifle
Heavy Plasma vs Sonic Cannon
Small Launcher vs Thermal Shok Launcher
Blaster Launcher vs Disruptor Pulse Launcher

Quantitative Analysis

Accuracy

Firepower

Other Discussions