Talk:Council of Funding Nations

Very interesting discussion! On the question of membership, perhaps membership of the CFN is similar to to membership of the European Space Agency or the Large Hadron Collider project. In other words, not a question of eligibility (like the UN) but simply a coalition of the willing. In short, the funding nations are simply those who were willing to pay. Of course, in exchange for their contribution they get a share in the spoils, preferential protection (reflected in the score & funding mechanics) and the power to set the rules of engagement.

on the legalities, perhaps the CFN adopted an earlier preceedent set by one of its members and defined UFO occupants ans craft as "illegal enemy combatants" and, as such, not subject to the laws or norms of war nor to civil protection. x-COM's apparent licence to destroy real estate with impunity and risk civilians in the crossfire is harder to explain. i expect a large and hidden part of X-COM's funding is tied up in expensive insurance, compensation, & hush money schemes.

Spike 14:08, 11 March 2008 (PDT)

Quid pro quo

Politics is never disinterested. In return for their financial contributions, the funding council nations received agreed material benefits:

1. Exclusive access to the spoils of operational missions at agreed, stable prices. X-COM could not auction the proceeds to the highest market bidder. Instead, proceeds were allocated to each nation in strict rotation. In the allocation of artefacts, each country's funding level determined both the precedence of allocation and the quantity of artefacts received. Once allocated the funding nations were free to trade or sell items to other FCN members, but not to other nations or the market. Clauses of the charter reserved to the FCN the right to act as a cartel and sell any collectively agreed surplus to the wider world, splitting the proceeds according to funding contributions.

2 All funding nations, equally, received all information gleaned from the project, including technologies. Nations were free to exploit this technology for internal use, but not to sell information or technology. Any manufactured goods sold would be subject to a royalty payable to the FCN and disbursed according to funding contributions.

3 Lastly, all nations received preferential protective treatment from X-COM forces, governed by a detailed technical appendix to the charter known as the Security Commitment Objectives - Resource Engagement (SCORE).

Spike 15:19, 11 March 2008 (PDT)

5th Geneva Convention

Convention V "Relative to the Covert Response to Exogenous Security Threats"

Declassified version, released 2023

Fifth Geneva Convention; Geneva, Helvetic Republic, 19 December 1998

Article 1

Whereas it has become necessary for the governments of this Earth to join together for their collective defence in the face of [classified], this Convention is hereby promulgated to regulate their joint endeavour.

Article 2

It is hereby declared and agreed that the exogenous threats, by nature of their [classified] and their demonstrated capacity for [classified], shall enjoy no protection under international law, including but not limited to the succeeding items.

Article 3

Conventions I, II, III and IV are hereby abrogated with respect to the [classified] personnel or [classified].

Article 4

The Hague Conventions of 1899 and 1907, and the Geneva Protocol of 1925, shall not apply to responses to the exogenous threat. For avoidance of doubt this includes any fragmentation, incendiary, chemical, biological, radiological, [classified], or [classified] weapon. Furthermore the nations wheresoever qualified reserve the option to delegate their right under Article IV.1 of the Nuclear Non Proliferation Treaty, 1969, to forces operating under authority of this convention in the event of a significant [classified], [classified], or other situation deemed to [classified].

Article 5

[classified] personnel or [classified] are illegal enemy combatants and are not entitled to the protection of any of the laws, customs or conventions of war, nor the protection of norms of civil and legal processes. Clearly, the notion of human rights is not applicable to [classified].

Article 6

International and domestic laws, norms and customs of maritime and aircraft navigation, prize law, arrest and interception of shipping (or aircraft) are not applicable to [classified], or any [classified] vessels, [classified], craft or other vehicles.

Article 7

Military, investigative, paramilitary, diplomatic, scientific, technical, medical, [classified] or [classified] personnel or forces acting under authority of this convention shall not be held liable in any jurisdiction, court, tribunal or arbitration process for any action directly or indirectly taken against exogenous threat personnel, [classified] or [classified] provided such action is conducted in accordance with the wider intent of this convention.

Article 8

Signatory governments commit to indemnify and save harmless any military, paramilitary and [classified] forces acting under authority of this convention in respect of any claimed or actual damages, lawsuit or [classified] arising from actions undertaken under authority of this convention, howsoever [classified], including but not limited to [classified], except in clear cases of gross and deliberate negligence.

Article 9

International and domestic laws pertaining to the treatment or welfare of domestic, agricultural, laboratory and experimental animals or [classified] shall not apply to operations or activities carried out during or in direct or indirect support of actions authorised by this convention, nor to [classified].

Article 10

The adminstration, interpretation and operation of the powers embodied in this convention shall be conducted by a Council of the signatory funding nations, exercising a vote proportionate to their agreed funding level and in the absence of consensus, by simple majority vote. The Council is hereby empowered to make any further required regulations or directives for operation of the executive, command, operational and material implementation of this convention, without further reference to the signatory funding nations. The Council shall remain the final arbiter and interpreting authority of the meaning of the convention.

Article 11

The creation, operation, maintenance and funding of such executive, command, operational and material means as are required to conduct the functions enabled by this convention are hereby authorised. The continuing existence and funding of the executive, command, operational and material forces in being is to be subject to a periodic vote of the council established under Article 10.

Article 12

Signatory nations shall use all means consistent with their internal laws and executive powers of government to preserve at all times and at all costs, including [classified] or if necessary [classified], the necessarily covert nature of this convention and all operations, institutions, activities and [classified] arising from its execution.

Article 13

[Classified]

Spike 16:30, 11 March 2008 (PDT)

Countries withdrawing from the CFN

Just a thought that occurred to me while reading this. There should be something touching on CFN groups that have chosen to withdraw that they still having certain obligations that are required of them (or even loss of some rights previously enjoyed). Just a few that I can think off the bat include:

• They are still required to maintain the secrecy of the project.
• X-Com still has exclusive rights to construct bases and operate in their territory as they see fit.

It makes me wonder, are withdrawing countries shifting their loyalty over to the aliens, or are they just turning a blind eye to the whole affair and just not caring what happens one way or the other?

- NKF 23:56, 11 March 2008 (PDT)

yes definitely should be residual obligations as you say. I agree that non membership is for a variety of reasons, such as not taking the alien threat seriously, not believing in XCom's ability, not wanting to provoke the aliens, etc. And even many of the funding countries may be playing a double game, supporting XCom while they see which way the wind blows and keeping their options open with the aliens: no doubt the aliens offer many inducements to cooperate: computer technology, lasers, stealth aircraft, cellular telephones, plasma-based consumer entertainment systems...

Spike 02:41, 12 March 2008 (PDT)